Ranking the Coaches

An article from CBS Sports about the stability and the hot seat of all of college football, so I will go over their list for the Mountain West and then I will have my own ranking of the coaches.

Here is the ranking system used by CBS

0-0.5 Don’t even think it — can’t be touched
1-1.5 Very safe — change highly unlikely
2-2.5 Safe — solid position
3-3.5 On the bubble — you never know
4-4.5 Warm seat — feeling the pressure
5 On the hot seat — it’s time to win now

Team Coach Years Record Ranking

Air Force Troy Calhoun 2 9-4 0.5

BYU Bronco Mendenhall 4 28-10 0.5

Colorado State Steve Fairchild 1 0-0 2.5

New Mexico Rocky Long 11 61-61 1.5

San Diego State Chuck Long 3 7-17 3.5

UNLV Mike Sanford 4 6-29 4

Utah Kyle Whittingham 4 24-14 1

Wyoming Joe Glenn 6 26-33 3

These rankings are pretty accurate, but I think Joe Glenn should be hire then Chuck Long.

Here is the list of ranking each coach on what they have done in the league.

1. Bronco Mendenhall, BYU: The biggest no brainer in the league, Mendenhall has a record of 28-10 and the last two years has ran the table in league play and also has two back to back 11 win seasons.

2. Gary Patterson, TCU: This was a close one between Utah coach Kyle Whittingham, but Patterson gets the nod for going undefeated his first year in conference play when TCU came into the Mountain West Conference play. If you were to include past performances Patterson could be number one but TCU has been in the WAC and C-USA before joining the MWC.

3. Kyle Whittingham, Utah: The only reason Whittingham is not higher is because he has yet to win a conference title. Whittingham after taken over the Utes has won 25 games and three straight bowl wins. Some of the time the coaching staff goes in slumps that reflects on the team as they are streaky.

4. Troy Calhoun, Air Force: Calhoun took over for long time coach Fisher DeBerry and took over a school that has had moderate success and decided to transform the offense, and most thought it would fail. However, Calhoun kept the running scheme in line because that was the players he had and moved the offense from a triple option to a spread run option and had excellent success by going 9-4 and making a bowl game in year one. This next season will be huge, because Air Force lost a ton of players to graduation.

5. Rock Long, New Mexico: New Mexico always seems to have talent, but for some reason the team keeps losing the close games and games where they are the favorite.  Long has a career 61-61 record at UNM, but has never had a conference title in his years at New Mexico.

6. Joe Glenn, Wyoming: Glenn used to be considered an up and coming coach who would soon be plucked to a big time program to lead the team.  While very successful in Laramie with its pinnacle win against UCLA in the 2004 Las Vegas Bowl, he has yet to put together an expected break out year.  With only one winning record Glenn is squarely on the hot seat at Wyoming.

7. Chuck Long, San Diego State: For all the players that were drafted and signed as free agents it is a wonder why the Aztecs are not better.  Long has had little success in two seasons in San Diego he is 7-17, and the team has shown minor improvement from year one to year two.  The defense needs to learn how to stop people for Long to be successful.  If Long has two more years like is first two he will be out of a job at that time.

8. Mike Sanford, UNLV:  This was the offensive genius that lead the Utah offense in 2003 and 2004 to new heights and a Fiesta Bowl win, and was a hot new coach.  With six wins in three seasons, Sanford has not progressed since he replaced John Robinson.  Sanford needs to show drastic improvement, which means at a minimum four wins this year to save his job and to keep the team competitive in the others.

N/A Steve Fairchild, Colorado State: Fairchild is not ranked, because it is his first year as a head coach. Fairchild hopes to follow Air Force’s Troy Calhoun with a bowl appearance in his first year.  Fairchild was around during the great years with the Rams.

Advertisements

2 Responses

  1. As it turned out, Utah’s Kyle Whittingham won National Coach of the Year honors (for ALL of D-1 college football) while Bronco Mendenhall was named the third or fourth best coach in the Mountain West Conference in 2008! Whittingham is CLEARLY a superior football coach over Mendenhall which explains why BYU did everything they could to lure Mendenhall as their head coach before finally having to settle for Mendenhall to replace Crowton.

    • CORRECTION: ……..which explains why BYU did everything they could to lure WHITTINGHAMl as their head coach before finally having to settle for Mendenhall to replace Crowton.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: